When this discussion about pet products first began, the goal was simple: highlight the idea that pet products made in the United States are inherently safer for our dogs. However, after reviewing available data and recall histories, that assumption becomes far less certain. Information about pet food and pet product safety is widely available online, but not all of it is accurate or presented with full context. It’s important to approach the topic thoughtfully, remain open-minded, and understand that no product—regardless of where it’s manufactured—is completely risk-free.
Do You Check Pet Food Labels Before Buying?
When you pick up dog food or a new toy, do you pause to read the label? Do you look for where the product was manufactured? If so, you’re part of a growing group of dog owners who are paying closer attention to ingredient sourcing and production locations. Across Utah and the rest of the country, many pet parents intentionally seek out products made in the United States because buying local feels safer and more responsible.
There’s a sense of comfort that comes from believing domestic manufacturing standards are higher. Feeding our dogs American-made food often feels like the healthiest choice. But does “Made in the USA” truly guarantee safety?
Pet Food Recalls Tell a Different Story
The reality is that recalls are not limited to imported products. In fact, 2017 alone saw 17 pet food and pet treat recalls, many involving well-known brands manufactured in the United States. Even companies that heavily market premium quality have faced issues.
For example, Blue Buffalo, a brand frequently advertised as superior to mainstream dog foods, has pulled products from shelves due to potential aluminum metal contamination in canned formulas. These recalls remind dog owners that higher price points do not automatically equal higher safety standards.
So if expensive food isn’t a foolproof solution, what should pet owners rely on instead?
A Look at Popular Dry Dog Foods and Recall Histories
Many of today’s most popular dry dog foods have experienced recalls at some point. That doesn’t necessarily mean they are unsafe—but it does reinforce the idea that no brand is immune to manufacturing risks.
Below is an overview of commonly recognized dry dog foods and their recall backgrounds:
Wellness Core
Wellness experienced a voluntary recall in March of that year involving a single canned product. The issue stemmed from potentially elevated levels of naturally occurring beef thyroid hormone in select grain-free varieties.
Taste of the Wild
This brand recalled dog and cat food in 2012 after testing positive for Salmonella, highlighting risks associated with shared manufacturing facilities.
Solid Gold Barking at the Moon
Solid Gold also issued recalls in 2012 due to production at the same Diamond Pet Foods manufacturing plant linked to other contamination concerns.
Orijen
Orijen has not issued recalls within the United States but has experienced recalls internationally, demonstrating how global supply chains can affect even premium brands.
Nature’s Variety Instinct (Duck Meal and Turkey Meal)
In 2016, Nature’s Variety voluntarily recalled a raw chicken formula due to potential Salmonella exposure.
Natural Balance Synergy
Natural Balance has issued multiple recalls since 2007 involving possible botulism and Salmonella contamination.
Merrick Classic Beef, Barley, and Carrot
Merrick recalled multiple food and treat products between 2010 and 2011 due to possible Salmonella presence.
The Honest Kitchen Embark
In 2013, three specific formulas—Verve, Thrive, and Zeal—were recalled after parsley used in production tested positive for Salmonella.
EVO Turkey and Chicken Meal Formula
EVO recalled products in 2014 due to incorrect vitamin and mineral levels and issued earlier recalls related to Salmonella contamination.
Canidae Single Grain Protein Plus
Canidae voluntarily recalled select dry foods in 2012 after Salmonella was detected at the manufacturing plant, which also produced food for other brands.
Is There Such a Thing as a Perfect Pet Product?
Simply put, no pet food is perfect—and none ever will be. Regulatory oversight from agencies like the FDA is relatively limited when it comes to dog food, even within the United States. While standards exist, they are not foolproof, and contamination can occur at multiple points in the supply chain.
Some dog owners choose to prepare homemade dog food using fresh ingredients they purchase themselves. While this approach offers greater control, it still carries risks. Even organic meats and produce can be contaminated with bacteria such as Salmonella.
Health Risks Extend Beyond Your Dog
Dogs can usually recover from Salmonella poisoning with veterinary care, often without hospitalization. However, the bacteria can be transmitted to humans—most commonly through contact with dog waste or contaminated surfaces.
If dog waste is handled improperly and hands are not washed thoroughly, humans can become infected. In people, Salmonella exposure often leads to serious illness and may require hospitalization. This risk underscores the importance of hygiene, regardless of what food your dog eats.
Making the Best Choice for Your Dog
The takeaway is not fear—but awareness. No brand, ingredient list, or country of origin guarantees absolute safety. What matters most is choosing a food that supports your dog’s health, monitoring how your dog responds, and staying informed about recalls.
If you ever have concerns about your dog’s diet, the best course of action is to speak directly with your veterinarian. They can help you evaluate nutritional needs, recommend trusted brands, or guide you through preparing balanced homemade meals if that’s your preference.
In the end, every dog is different—and the “right” choice is the one that keeps your dog healthy, active, and thriving.
This post is brought to you by Rocky Mountain Pooper Scoopers. They proudly serve the Greater Salt Lake City area, including Sandy, West Jordan, and Taylorsville, offering dependable and affordable pet waste removal services. Call (385) 392-0791 today for your free estimate—weekly rates start at just $18.00. Visit their website at rockymountainpooperscoopers.com to read reviews and learn more.
Happy Tails!
